Radon measuring devices experience - airthings wave radoneye air-q radon comparison picture

Radon measuring devices in the test: comparison between RadonEye, air-Q radon science and Airthings Wave Plus (from left to right)

Invisible and yet dangerous: the radioactive gas radon can occur unnoticed indoors. To detect it, you need a radon measuring device. With the air-Q itself, we offer a highly developed measuring device. We have tested how well the air-Q radon science performs in comparison with the RadonEye and the Airthings Wave Plus.

Note: We have compared all functions as objectively as possible and present the most important features of the three measuring devices in a direct comparison. We hope that our product test will help you to gain a comprehensive overview.

What is radon and how is it produced?

Radon is an invisible, odorless radioactive gas that is produced by uranium decay in the ground and rises to the surface. It can enter houses through fine cracks or fissures in foundations. Due to its physical properties, it often accumulates in basements or on the first floor. However, it can also penetrate to higher floors through gaps and air ducts (e.g. sockets or heating pipes).

Where does it occur particularly frequently?

Radon can occur anywhere, but is more common in regions with uranium-containing subsoil. In Germany, parts of Saxony, Thuringia, Bavaria and Baden-Württemberg are particularly affected. There are also risk areas near mountains in other countries, e.g. in parts of the Alps, the Rocky Mountains or in granite-rich regions. Outdoors, there is usually no danger from radon because it is quickly dispersed and diluted by the wind.

Danger from radon

The WHO ranks radon as the second biggest cause of lung cancer (only smoking is worse). This underlines how important it is to monitor this health risk. In our radon measuring device test, we compare three measuring devices: air-Q radon, Airthings Wave Plus and RadonEye. These devices allow you to check radon levels in your home or workplace and track them over time to identify and respond to potential radon sources.

1. comparison of the sensor equipment

Our three radon measuring devices are equipped with different sensors. Depending on the model, the measuring devices also offer other sensors in addition to the radon measurement value to measure various air parameters. We have summarized the measured values of the devices in the following table.

We have compared the specifications of the Radon sensor of the respective devices:

Radon sensor specifications:
RadonEye
"
Sensor: pulsed ionization chamber
"
Measuring intervals: 10 min
"
Resolution: 0.1 Bq / m³
"
Arbeitsbereich: 10°C - 40°C; Luftfeuchtigkeit < 90 %
"
Measuring range: 1 ~ 3,700 Bq/m³
"
Messab­weichung: < ±10 % (nach 1h erreicht)
Radon sensor specifications:
AirThings Wave Plus
"
Sensor: Passive diffusion chamber
"
Measuring intervals: Radon: 1h; other values 5 min
"
Resolution: 0.1 Bq / m³
"
Arbeitsbereich: 4°C - 40°C; Luftfeuchtigkeit < 85%
"
Measuring range: 1 ~ 20,000 Bq/m³
"
Measurement deviation: after 7 days ~ 10 % after 2 months ~ 5 %
Radon sensor specifications:
air-Q radon science
"
Sensor: continuous pulse counting
"
Measuring intervals: mathematical evaluation via Kalman filter every 2 seconds
"
Resolution: 0.1 Bq / m³
"
Arbeitsbereich: 0°C - 50°C; Luftfeuchtigkeit < 95%
"
Measuring range: 0 - 1,000,000 Bq/m³
"
Messab­weichung: < ±10 % (nach 1h erreicht)

2. connection options and handling of the measuring devices

When buying a radon meter, design and handling are important in addition to accuracy. We have therefore compared connection options and external features. The display of the Radon-Eye, which makes it possible to read the measured values without a smartphone app, should be emphasized. However, the display is very small, so you have to stand directly in front of the device. Data is stored every 1 hour for over a year. The device has a proprietary power supply and can only be operated with the supplied power supply unit and plug.

The Airthings Wave Plus is battery-operated and can be attached to the wall. It also has an LED color display that can be activated by hand gesture and indicates the air quality (green, yellow, red). For the hand gesture to work, you have to move your hand directly above the device.

The air-Q radon science has a high-resolution LED display that can be freely configured. The measured values of the individual sensors can also be read from a distance. The device is powered via a USB-C connection so that commercially available power supply units can be used. The air-Q radon science also has a removable SD card that contains the recorded measurement data in CSV format. The memory is sufficient for more than 10 years of data at 2-minute intervals. Furthermore, the USB port in the air-Q radon science is active, i.e. the device can be connected directly to a computer. This function is available on the hardware side, but will only be activated later via a firmware update.

RadonEye comparison packaging

RadonEye: compact and informative

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Proprietary power supply
-
Bluetooth connection
-
Stable stand
-
Logs data for 1 year at 1h intervals
-
Small number display
airthings wave comparison packaging

Airthings: flexible and interactive

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Battery operated
-
Wall mounting option
-
Bluetooth connection
-
Gesture-controlled color traffic light (red, yellow, green)
air-Q comparison packaging

air-Q radon science: professional and versatile

keyboard_arrow_down
-
USB-C power supply
-
Long-range WLAN
-
Removable SD card for virtually unlimited high-resolution measurement data
-
Freely configurable LED display recognizable even from a distance
-
Active USB port

3. commissioning and network setup

After a short self-test, the RadonEye is ready for operation as soon as it is switched on, i.e. it shows Radon measurement values on its own display, which should show the specified accuracy after one hour. The Radon Eye can be connected to the EcoSense app via Bluetooth. It takes about two minutes to set up, during which the device code must be entered manually. After that, measurement data can be retrieved whenever the smartphone is near the device. It is not possible to retrieve measurement data via the Internet.

The Airthings Wave Plus can be set up quickly without any manual input.
After inserting the batteries, the device is found via Bluetooth and displayed in the app. Exactly one Airthings device can be integrated into a user account. A name and location can be assigned. The process takes approx. 3-4 minutes. However, reliable measurement data is only available after several days. Measurement data can only be retrieved when you are near the device with your smartphone. It is possible to retrieve measurement data via the Internet, but this must first be uploaded via the smartphone after manually connecting to the Airthings device via Bluetooth. The Airthings Wave Plus cannot send the data to the Internet itself if the user / smartphone is not connected via Bluetooth - a manual process.

The air-Q radon science boots up within 30 seconds of plugging in the power supply unit. After starting, a Wi-Fi network can be found into which a PC or smartphone / tablet can dial in. The WLAN, device name, location and a device password can then be configured using the air-Q app or the PC. The setup takes approx. 2-4 minutes and is somewhat more error-prone than a Bluetooth configuration, as there are more potential sources of error (e.g. typing errors with the Wi-Fi key; repeaters; blocked ports, etc.).
The air-Q can be integrated into several user accounts. This is important as each user can use their own settings (e.g. push alarms). Internet access is not mandatory. The air-Q can also be operated alone in the local network or even without, i.e. mobile. If the air-Q is connected to the WLAN and the free air-Q Cloud is to be used, the data can be accessed from anywhere, as the air-Q automatically transfers the data to the air-Q Cloud every two minutes.

RadonEye experience picture

RadonEye

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Bluetooth based setup
-
no Internet obligation, but also no Internet possibility.
-
Stable stand
-
rudimentary app
-
Measured values immediately after start
airthings wave experience picture

Airthings Wave Plus

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Bluetooth based setup
-
Internet is mandatory
-
One user account per measuring device
-
Long lead time until measured values are reliable
air-Q experience picture

air-Q radon science

keyboard_arrow_down
-
More complex WLAN setup, but more convenient operation later on
-
No Internet obligation
-
High level of data protection
-
Multiple users per measuring device
-
Measured values immediately after start

4. charts, data & measurement results

All three measuring devices offer their own free smartphone apps for Android and iOS. These offer different functions for displaying and analyzing the measured data for radon and the other sensors. The current measured values, charts / diagrams of historical data and additional information can be displayed. Some of the collected data (Airthings Wave Plus and air-Q radon science) can also be displayed in a web app.

RadonEye comparison app

RadonEye: Basic functions

keyboard_arrow_down
The RadonEye displays current measured values every minute and provides basic chart functions, such as the display of individual values as well as average, maximum and minimum values. However, there is no time and date information and the graph options are very limited. It is not possible to select a time period. It remains unclear which period is displayed at all. Data can only be exported as a simple text file without a time stamp.

The RadonEye concentrates on its core function as a measuring device and does without integrated tips or additional help. It offers pure measurement functionality without additional advice or support.
airthings wave comparison app

Airthings Wave Plus: different time periods

keyboard_arrow_down
The Airthings Wave Plus outputs current measurement data within a few minutes. The device offers data visualization in the form of charts for time periods of three hours, one day, seven days, 30 days and one year - custom time periods, e.g. a specific day in the past, cannot be set. However, (only) one value at a time can be displayed in the chart. Current values and average values can also be displayed.

The Airthing app provides structured assistance. The tips are divided into phases, with users receiving support immediately after installation and after 7 and 30 days. In addition, users have access to a comprehensive Help Center for further information and assistance.
air-Q comparison app

air-Q radon science: Detailed analyses

keyboard_arrow_down
The air-Q radon offers a wide range of analysis options. Current measured values are output every second - in real time. Users can use a quick picker or set completely flexible time periods for the evaluation of historical data. There is no time limit - theoretically, the air-Q offers storage space for well over 10 years of data with a data resolution of two minutes. The display allows up to two values to be compared simultaneously - either two sensors of one air-Q device or two identical sensors of two devices (via the web app). Limit values and self-set barriers can be displayed as an option. Versatile export options are available for further analysis, including image, CSV and Excel formats (web app).

The air-Q app offers comprehensive information on the measured variables and data and provides information on causes and possible health effects. The individual solution suggestions and personalized tips for poor air quality are particularly useful. A brand new feature is an AI advisor that evaluates the measured values individually and live at the touch of a button.

Comparison of measurement results:

As part of our investigation, the three radon measuring devices were subjected to a comparative test over a period of one week. In order to be able to compare the measurement data directly, they were inserted into a common diagram.

While the RadonEye and the air-Q radon show a similar, very dynamic curve, the curve of the Airthings Wave Plus differs greatly. In particular, the data of the Airthings shows a significantly lower dynamic, while the maximum value of the other two devices is approximately reached. Nevertheless, typical patterns caused by air exchange (ventilation) in the room are only visible with a significant time delay or not at all on the Airthings Wave Plus. This significantly reduced sensitivity can be attributed to the passive measuring method.

However, it should be emphasized that this assumption is merely a hypothesis. However, in several independent tests involving additional devices, the Airthings measuring device showed consistently deviating and significantly lower radon concentrations compared to the other measuring systems.

RadonEye airthings ware air-Q radon sensors comparison graphic

5. setting options

Individual setting options are crucial for user-friendliness and adaptability. They make it possible to adapt the measuring device to individual requirements - from LED brightness and units of measurement to alarm threshold values. We have compared the three radon meters.

RadonEye comparison app

RadonEye - rudimentary setting options

keyboard_arrow_down
The RadonEye only offers a few settings that are displayed in a category: Users can delete stored data, adjust the unit of measurement and set an alarm threshold at which the device beeps.
airthings wave comparison app

Airthings Wave Plus - Basic settings

keyboard_arrow_down
The Airthings device allows a little more customization and is also designed for multiple devices. More sensors also mean more settings can be made. Units of measurement and various notifications can be configured, as well as a dark mode. It also offers an integrated help and support area.
air-Q comparison app

air-Q radon science - customizability and many additional functions

keyboard_arrow_down
With ten setting categories, the air-Q radon offers many settings and options for customization. These include options for customizing the LED display with different themes, night mode, configurable cloud data storage, alarms / push messages, calibration functions and a dark mode as well as other settings for individualizing the app interface. There are also many professional settings and information about the device.

6. internationality / language settings

Not all of the three test devices are set up internationally. Some of the smartphone app and operating instructions are only available in English. Due to the technical terms used, user-friendliness and accessibility may be limited in some cases.

RadonEye: App in English

The RadonEye "EcoSense" app is only available in English. The operating instructions, on the other hand, are available in seven different languages.

Airthings Wave Plus: product app in English

The Airthings app is also only available in English. However, the operating instructions are available in nine different languages.

air-Q radon: multilingual app and web app

The air-Q app is available in three languages: German, English and French. The operating instructions are available in two languages: German and English. We have it on good authority that a Spanish version is planned for the near future.

7. alarm functions / push messages

The most important functions of monitoring devices include alarms in critical situations. Alarm functions are particularly important for radioactive radon in order to react quickly to critical values and stay healthy and safe.

RadonEye offers email notifications and app alerts that inform users when set limits are exceeded. However, these functions are only available within Bluetooth range, which limits remote monitoring.

Various predefined push notifications can be activated in the Airthings Wave Plus app. sends push notifications for various air quality parameters in the app. Users can individually define for which measured values and threshold values these notifications should be sent.

air-Q radon offers multiple alarm types: Visual alarms through the set LED theme, push or email notifications for remote monitoring, gas alarm and fire alarm, and AI-based alarms to intelligently detect various situations and air quality changes.

RadonEye comparison app alarm function

RadonEye

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Simple acoustic notifications on the device
-
Only works when you are near the device, as a Bluetooth connection is required
-
No push messages
airthings wave comparison app alarm function

Airthings Wave Plus

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Ready-made push messages
-
Only works when you are near the device, as a Bluetooth connection is required
air-Q comparison app alarm function

air-Q radon science

keyboard_arrow_down
-
Customizable push and email notifications for Radon and all other sensors
-
Additional fire and gas alarm as visual, audible alarm and push message can be set individually
-
Smart alarms for cigarette smoke, presence and offline

8. remote monitoring

The ability to access data from anywhere is particularly beneficial for travelers or for monitoring multiple locations.

RadonEye only allows access to measurement data within Bluetooth range. Users can receive alerts, but only if they are in the vicinity.

Airthings Wave Plus enables remote monitoring but requires an additional device, the SmartLink Hub, which is not included. With this hub, users can retrieve real-time data and receive notifications when limit values are exceeded.

air-Q radon offers comprehensive remote access. Users can read out the device data from anywhere and receive individually configured notifications. This enables efficient air quality monitoring, even when you are not on site.

9 Conclusion: Which radon measuring device is right for you?

Each of the appliances presented has its strengths and is suitable for different needs:

RadonEye: A good solution for users who need an uncomplicated and selective radon measurement. The device concentrates on the core function without additional features, which makes it particularly user-friendly for beginners. There is simply a display where you can read the current value. This works without a smartphone app, but also offers no assistance.

Airthings: Recommended for users who value customizable data visualization. In addition to radon measurement, the Airthings Wave Plus offers other important air quality parameters that are also recorded. With the good app, the device has more functions than the RadonEye, but it cannot be used without the app.

air-Q radon science: The air-Q offers the most comprehensive analysis options, together with many setting and alarm options. It also has the most additional sensors besides radon. The integrated remote access enables remote monitoring and control, ideal for smart home enthusiasts or people who want to keep an eye on multiple locations and many different air values. Even without an app, the air-Q radon science offers readability in 30 Bq/m³ increments up to approx. 500 Bq/m³ thanks to the color scale. The app provides additional information, charts and limit values as well as a health advisor.